Wednesday 28 April 2010

Stories and RPGs

I had the chance to catch up on a lot of TV recently, and I noticed a lot of things that just don't seem to be features of most RPGs I've played over the years.

Most scenes have only two characters. Even if there are background characters, the scene is about the relationship or interaction of two characters. Of course there are scenes with more than two, but they don't make up the majority. Compare this to RPGs, in which the whole party is always present, all the time (and often with all their stuff in pockets and backpacks).

Most scene transitions don't care about travel. If a scene needs a character who was on the other side of the city just a moment ago, the character just appears in the next one. Sometimes it's represented by a knock on the door, or something similar, but the travel itself doesn't usually matter. And this applies to a wider range of things, not just travel. We need to remember in RPGs that we can skip some details without adversely affecting the story. Even if you want a William Gibson story, he leaves out the unnecessary details especially when he includes what seems to be atmospheric details. Only keep what you need.

Violence is a small part of TV shows, even action shows. With the exception of in media res, action is always preceded by lots and lots of talking, all of which builds to the tension that seems only to be resolved by violence. Most TV characters don't use violence as the first choice for solving problems, but in RPGs, it's a huge part of the game. See Rob Donoghue's Some Space to Think: Children and Tasers for more about this perspective.

And so on and so on. I think that game designers, GMs and players need to think about what they want from an RPG and play accordingly. Although, I think that if you really want all action all the time, you'll probably feel better playing a miniatures game than an RPG or story game.

Labels

1KM1KT (1) 3:16 Carnage Amongst The Stars (1) 4ZZZ (1) A Penny For My Thoughts (6) Abney Park (1) Actual Play (13) Administration (3) Adults only please (1) Advanced Dungeons and Dragons (5) Advanced Fighting Fantasy (4) Agon (14) Andrew Smith (1) Apocalypse World (3) apocalyptic (1) Art (2) Aspects (1) Auscon (11) Australian Game Designers (1) Avengers (1) Battlestar Galactica (1) Behind The Screens (1) Bits and Mortar (2) Blades In The Dark (1) Blank Shield Press (1) Brass Goggles (1) Braunstein (3) Brick Battles (2) Brisbane (5) Burning Wheel (33) Campaign (1) Car Wars (5) Car Wars Tanks (2) Chess (1) Chick Corea (1) Chris Perkins (1) convention (1) Convention tips (1) conventions (1) Cosplay (1) Cthulhu (1) Cubicle 7 (1) CW6 (1) Cylon (1) D&D (1) D&D 5e (1) Daniel Solis (1) David Pidgeon (6) Death Race (1) Design (11) DeviantArt (1) Diaspora (7) Dice and Clouds (1) Dicebook (1) Discordia.se (1) Divine Trauma (2) Do (1) Dogs in the Vineyard (3) Don't Lose Your Mind (2) Don't Rest Your Head (24) DramaSystem (6) Dresden Files RPG (3) DRYH (4) Duel of Wits (1) Dungeon (1) dungeon crawl (2) Dungeons and Dragons (8) Dungeons and Dragons Pennny Arcade (2) Elizabeth I (1) Embers of the Forgotten Kingdom (1) encounters (1) Erick Wujcik (1) Escape or Die (1) Every Gamer's Guild (7) Evil Hat (7) F20 (1) Fat Dragon Games (1) FATE (6) Fate Core (4) Feng Shui 2 (1) Fenix (1) Fiasco (4) Fred Hicks (7) Free RPG Adventure Ideas (2) Free RPG Blog (2) From the news (3) FU (7) FU RPG (4) Fudge (1) fundamentalism (1) Gail Simone (1) Game Chef (1) game design (14) Game of Thrones (5) Game theory (2) Gamer dad (2) Gaming (3) Gaming gear (1) Gary Gygax (1) Gen Con Oz (8) GenCon (31) Gettin' Away With It (4) GM advice (1) GM style (2) GM Technique (8) Go Play Brisbane (26) golf (1) Good and Evil (1) google hangouts (1) Grey Ranks (3) GUMSHOE (1) GURPS (1) Hamlet's Hit Points (1) Happy Birthday Robot (3) Here Be Gamers (3) Heroica (1) Hillfolk (1) Horror (1) Houses of the Blooded (2) Indie Game Designer (4) indie gamers (1) Indie Games Explosion (11) indie games on demand (9) Indie Press Gang (2) Indie Press Revolution (3) Indie RPG (14) Inquisitor (1) iPad (1) IPR (4) Jason Morningstar (1) John Cleese (1) John Harper (5) John Hodgman (1) John Locke (1) John Reid (2) John Wick (1) Kenneth Hite (1) Kickstarter (2) kill puppies for satan (2) Knightmare Chess (1) Kuang Hong (1) Lady Blackbird (2) LARP (1) Lego (4) Lego Agonica (1) Lego FU (11) Long Beach Geeks (1) LoveHate Design (1) Lulu (2) Machiavelli (1) Madman (1) magic (2) Magic Burner (1) Major Wesely (1) Mark McPherson (1) Mark Peric (3) Marvel Super Heroes (1) May The FU Be With You (2) Mechaton (1) mf0 (1) Michael Wenman (6) miniatures gaming (1) Mixel (1) Mobile Frame Zero (5) Monopoly (1) Monty Haul (1) Munchkin (2) Mutant City Blues (1) My Kitchen Rules (1) My Life With Master (1) NaGaDeMon (17) Nagademon 2013 (6) Nagademon 2015 (2) Narrative Control (2) Nathan Russell (9) Neology (1) Neoncon (1) Nietzsche (1) Ninja vs Pirates (1) Nobles (14) Nuria (2) O Mortal (10) One-shot (1) Organising Games (1) Orphan Black (1) parenting (1) Paul Tevis (2) PDF (3) Perception Check (1) Peril Planet (3) Perth (2) Peter Adkinson (1) Peter Adkison (1) Peter Blake (6) Philosophy (3) Pictionary (1) Pirates Showdown (1) Play report (1) play style (1) Playtesting (2) Pocketmod (1) Podcast (3) Podcast of Foes (1) Poison'd (18) Poleconomy (1) Power 19 (1) Primetime Adventures (13) psychology (1) Publishing (2) Quality Comics (1) Queen (2) Religion in gaming (6) Rifts (1) Rob Donoghue (1) Robin Laws (6) Robotech (1) Roleplaying skills (2) Roll20 (1) RPG (9) RPG Advice (2) RPG Podcast Review (1) RPGNow (1) RWBY (1) Ryan Macklin (1) SacredVows (1) Sagefight (2) Scott Haring (1) Scott Vandervalk (1) Scrabble (1) Scribd (1) Sean Nittner (1) Second Generation Gamer (1) semiotics (1) Seth Godin (1) Setting Hack (3) Shakespeare (1) Siege (40) Silence of the Lambs (1) Skrillex (1) Skype (2) Skyrim (1) Smallville (1) Social contract (1) solo gaming (1) Sons of Kryos (1) Sons of Liberty (1) Space Rat (5) speculative fiction (1) Spirit of the Century (21) Star Wars (8) steampunk (1) Steve Darlington (1) Steve Jackson Games (3) Storn Cook (1) Story games (12) Sucker Punch (1) Supanova (2) Super Gachapon Fighter Omega Infinity (1) Superman (1) Swancon (2) Swashbucklers of the 7 Skies (1) Swords (1) Taboos (1) Tactics (1) Tales From The Floating Vagabond (1) Talk Like A Pirate (1) That's How We Roll (1) The Beast of Limfjord (1) The Bones (1) The Cells (10) The Eighth Sea (3) The Forge (4) The Lego Movie (3) The MESSAGE (1) The Mountain Witch (1) The Spark RPG (1) The Stockade (8) The Walking Eye (3) Them They and Those Guys (1) Theory (2) Theory From the Closet (2) Timothy Ferguson (1) Transformers (1) Twitter (1) Unlit Match (9) Uprising (6) Victor Wooten (1) Vincent Baker (7) War Showdown (1) Warhammer (2) Warhammer 40K (1) Will Hindmarch (1) world building (1) WOTC (2) XKCD (1) Zedgames (5) Zombie Cinema (3)